Writing about a warming climate and the places people live and work.
Transmission towers and power lines against a dusk sky
Transmission lines carry bulk power between regions. Most outages customers experience begin further down, on the local distribution system.

Two bad seasons for the grid

For most of the last fifty years, planning an American electric system meant planning for one bad hour: a weekday afternoon in late July, air conditioning running everywhere at once, demand at its annual maximum. Everything else was slack. Utilities scheduled maintenance in the winter because winter was when the system had room.

That assumption has been coming apart from both ends. Summer peaks are still there and still growing, but winter mornings now produce events of comparable severity, and the winter version tends to be worse when it fails, because the failure arrives with the heating load.

Why winter got harder

  1. Heating turned electric. Heat pumps and electric resistance heat move a load that used to sit on the gas system onto the wires. In a cold snap that load peaks early in the morning, before the sun is up and while wind is often light.
  2. Gas supply and gas generation fail together. Wellheads freeze, compressor stations lose power, and gas plants lose fuel at the exact hour they are needed. The February 2021 storm in Texas is the reference case. Roughly 4.5 million customers lost power, some for days, and the state's official death count reached 246. Most of the lost generation was thermal, and a large share of that was gas that could not get fuel.
  3. Cold spreads over a wide area. A regional heat wave usually leaves a neighbor with power to sell. A continental cold outbreak hits the neighbors at the same time, so the imports that normally cover a shortfall are not available. Winter Storm Elliott in December 2022 pushed systems from the Gulf to the mid-Atlantic into emergency procedures on the same night.

Summer has its own new shape. Solar generation has flattened the middle of the day in California, Texas and the Southwest, which moves the tightest hour to the early evening, when output falls off and demand is still high. Batteries have taken over much of that window and have performed well, though four hours of storage covers an evening ramp rather than a three-day event. The harder summer problem is a heat wave that runs a week with warm nights, because equipment on the distribution system depends on overnight cooling to shed the heat it built up during the day. A transformer that never gets below 85 degrees at night is running hot on day four, and its insulation ages on a curve where a few extra degrees cut service life sharply.

That distinction matters when the conversation turns to generation. Generation shortfalls make headlines, and they are the ones that cause rolling blackouts across a whole region. The great majority of outage minutes a customer actually experiences start on the local distribution system: a tree on a line, a pole down in a wind event, a failed transformer on their own street. Those failures track vegetation, wind, ice and heat, and the money that fixes them goes into tree trimming, pole inspection and undergrounding.

What makes this hard to fix quickly is the schedule. A new transmission line takes ten to fifteen years from proposal to energization, and most of that is siting, permitting and litigation across multiple jurisdictions rather than construction. Interconnection queues in several regions hold more proposed generation than the entire installed fleet, with wait times measured in years. The load, meanwhile, has started growing again after two decades of flat demand, driven by data centers, new manufacturing and electrified transport.

The measures that move fastest reduce the peak instead of adding to supply: demand response programs that pay large customers to drop load, time-of-use rates that shift water heating and car charging out of the critical hour, and weatherization requirements on generators and gas infrastructure of the kind Texas adopted after 2021. All of them are cheap next to building capacity that runs a few hours a year.

Back to the index